Canada to Join Mexico in Complaint on US Car-Origin Rules

Canada to Join Mexico in Complaint on US Car-Origin Rules


Canada plans to formally join Mexico in calling for an arbitration panel to resolve a dispute with the US over how to interpret rules governing the origin of vehicle parts.

The two countries expect to request in the first days of January the creation of a tribunal of experts to rule on the matter as allowed under the US-Mexico-Canada Agreement, known as USMCA, according to three people familiar with the plans. The individuals spoke on condition they not be identified because they aren’t authorised to speak publicly on the issue.

Canada Trade Minister Mary Ng’s office didn’t immediately respond to requests for comment.

The conflict focuses on differences over how to calculate the percentage of a vehicle that comes collectively from the three countries. Both Mexico and Canada believe the trade deal stipulates that more regionally produced parts should count toward duty-free shipping than the US wants to allow. Motor vehicles are the top manufactured product traded between the three countries.

The panel — whose findings are binding — will be tasked with deciding whether the US application of the content rules, known as rules of origin, is inconsistent with the trade pact.

Canada and Mexico can seek the formation of a three- or five-member panel chosen from a roster of legal and trade experts previously agreed to under USMCA. The panel process would be finished at earliest the start of July 2022, based on timelines laid out in the trade deal, according to an August report from attorneys from White & Case.

If the tribunal finds the US is violating the terms of the pact, President Joe Biden’s administration will be obliged to seek a negotiated resolution. If talks fail, Canada and Mexico could impose an equivalent “suspension of benefits,” such as higher tariffs.

The panel is the next step allowed under the dispute resolution mechanism of the trade agreement, after discussions between Mexico and the US failed to settle the disagreement.

It would also represent an escalation for Canada, which has said it had only been monitoring talks between its two trading partners as an interested third party.

But Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who was re-elected with a minority government in September, has faced pressure from business leaders — particularly from the nation’s car industry — to become more aggressive against what Canadians sees as growing US trade protectionism.

Over the past few weeks, Canada and the US have clashed over Biden’s push to grant additional tax rebates for electric vehicles built by unionised American workers. The US, meanwhile, has pushed back against a Canadian proposal for levies on US-based tech giants. Increased US duties on softwood lumber and a halt to shipments of potatoes from Atlantic Canada are also causing friction.

The Canadian government announced that it is challenging US duties on Canadian softwood lumber through the USMCA’s dispute resolution mechanism. Trudeau instructed his top economic ministers to take tougher positions on trade issues amid growing disputes with the US.